Rapture Miscalculations

RevelationWhile not foundational to a belief and relationship with Christ, “Rapture” theology has relatively recent Anglo/American origins. ♦

It was in the spring of 2011 that there were bold predictions of “the Rapture” by so-called Bible scholar, Harold Camping. These prognostications received expected media coverage that ranged from restrained tongue-in-cheek reporting to outright ridicule. As the target date and time approached it was interesting to gauge the reactions of people as it became a broader news story. One heard questions and comments from friends and colleagues that ranged from “Could it be true?” to “Who is this person?” to even “What’s the Rapture?” It was a rare person who had not actually heard the story that some man and his followers were predicting the “end of the world.”

False Recalibration
 When the doom-hour came and went Camping recalculated that October 2011 was the correct date. Of course, this time came and went as well. He quietly slinked away and has since admitted his error(s) and has promised to not predict end-time events again.

This yet another flawed prophetic non-event serves up an opportunity to highlight some confusion on this topic, even amongst Christians.

Late Great Predictions
The Pew Research Center notes that 41% of Americans believe that “Jesus will definitely or probably return for the faithful before 2050.” That’s out of 78% of American adults who claim to be Christian. We may be predominantly Christian but many are confused about End Times eschatology and loaded topics like “the Rapture.”

For many US Baby Boomers, their Christianity was influenced by popular books written about the End Times such as Hal Lindsey’s Late Great Planet Earth (1970) and Tim LaHaye’s Left Behind series (1995). Many Fundamentalists and Evangelicals believe the popularized view that the God of Abraham’s “Final Judgment” follows a literal and exact 1000-year golden Christian reign on earth. Lindsey’s “pre-millennial” view purports this Millennium occurs only after a climactic struggle (between Israel and Russia, claimed Lindsey) preceded by a “Rapture” or taking-up of all born-again Christ believers out of a time of trials and “Tribulation” prior to an assault on Israel led by the Antichrist (666) figure.

Seems simple and straight-forward and somewhat along the lines of what one has read, heard or even believes, right? What’s not widely known about this view is it’s dubious 19th century origins and reasons for its primarily North American belief base.

Debatable Teaching
Since Christ’s own prediction of His “coming return” in Matthew 24 there have been speculation and side-bets on dates and time-tables. Lindsey’s and LaHaye’s wooden interpretation of scripture were based on flawed foundational teaching that arose out of the 1830s embraced by John Nelson Darby, an early leader of an English fundamentalist movement that became known as Dispensationalism. Darby’s view of the Rapture (a word which actually never appears in Scriptures) was then picked up by an American follower named C. I. Scofield, who taught the view in the footnotes of his popular Scofield Reference Bible, first published in 1909 and then widely distributed in America across many leading seminaries. The impact was on a whole generation of Bible leaders, pastors and teachers like Harold Camping.

Future postings will address alternative views.

“But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father.” (Matthew 24:36)

Categories: End Times, Prophecy, Theology

Tags: , , , , ,

3 replies

  1. Greetings friend, I’m Melissa Crawford and I appreciate the prophecy that I found on your webpage. My husband wanted me to invite you to share with our live video streaming e-revival audience as soon as possible. At Spirit University he is training a team of prophetic students and we are all receiving end time visions, dreams and words like yours. One of our students has been seeing fireballs falling from Heaven and as you know, one actually fell on Russia.

    Many other prophetic signs are being confirmed at our e-Revival.

    Everyone receives a prophetic word by my husband James Crawford; if they request one and we have an e-Revival every day! We would love to have you or anybody else’s prophecies shared at God’s revival!

    Times you can call in to share:
    Mon – Fri at 10:45 am & 7 pm (central)
    Sat. at 4 pm (central)
    Sun. at 11 am (central)

    Feel free to call our cell at (318) 655-2297 or email james@world-hops.com for more information.

    Keep up the good work and God bless you.


  2. Is Hal Lindsey’s proof for a pretrib rapture “100 proof” – that is, 100 percent Biblical?
    In “The Late Great Planet Earth” (p. 143) Lindsey gives his “chief reason” for pretrib: “If the Rapture took place at the same time as the second coming, there would be no mortals left who would be believers” – that is, no believers still alive who could enter the millennium and repopulate the earth.
    We don’t know if Lindsey’s amnesia is voluntary or involuntary, but earlier (p. 54), while focusing on chapters 12 through 14 of Zechariah, Lindsey sees “a remnant of Jews in Jerusalem” who are mortals who will become believing mortals at the second coming and then become repopulating mortals!
    During the same discussion of Zech. 12-14 Lindsey overlooks some of the final verses in Zech. 14. They reveal that some of the tribulation survivors “of all the nations which came against Jerusalem” will refuse to go there “to worship the King, the Lord of hosts.” Here’s what will happen to those “heathen” rebels: “upon them shall be no rain.”
    So the facts about the repopulating mortals, in unbelieving as well as believing ranks, cancel out Lindsey’s “chief reason” for opposing a joint rapture/second coming – the ONLY rapture view to be found in official theology books and organized churches prior to 1830!
    (See historian Dave MacPherson’s “The Rapture Plot,” the most accurate and most highly endorsed book on pretrib rapture history. Also Google “Pretrib Rapture Stealth,” “Pretrib Rapture Pride,” “Pretrib Rapture Secrecy” and “Pretrib Rapture Dishonesty.”)
    Although Hal Lindsey claims that his “Late Great” didn’t set a date for Christ’s return, many of his followers – including copycats Bill Maupin (“1981”) and Edgar Whisenant (“1988”) – did view Lindsey as a date-setter, and his later book “The 1980s: Countdown to Armageddon” (the sort of title that date-setters and their ga-ga groupies love) became another fizzle – unless we’re still living in the 1980s!
    In Old Testament days false prophets were stoned to death. Today they’re just stoned!


  3. Thanks, Rocky. You’ve done your homework.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: